KEY TAKEAWAYS
In May 2004, a soft-spoken patent attorney from Connecticut won the biggest prize poker had ever paid. Greg “Fossilman” Raymer beat a record field of 2,576 entries to win the World Series of Poker Main Event and $5,000,000, finishing off David Williams in a seven-hand heads-up match at Binion’s Horseshoe in Las Vegas. Like Chris Moneymaker the year before, he had won his seat online.
Raymer’s win is often remembered as the sequel to Moneymaker’s. It was also proof that the 2003 result had not been a one-off. The Main Event had more than tripled in a single year, online satellites were now feeding hundreds of players into it, and the final two players were both online qualifiers. This article tells the story of the 2004 Main Event: who Raymer was, how he built and used his chip lead, how the final hand played out, and what the result revealed about the poker boom. It is drawn from Card Player’s history of the event, WSOP.com’s official results, Associated Press reports from the time and PokerNews, and it notes where those accounts disagree.
The Year After Moneymaker
The Main Event that Raymer won was a different event from the one Moneymaker had won twelve months earlier. PokerNews lists the 2003 field at 839 entries. In 2004, it reached 2,576 entries and a prize pool of $24,224,400, according to WSOP.com’s official results. Card Player wrote that the field shattered every prior attendance record in poker.
The growth changed how the tournament ran. Card Player reports that the schedule was expanded to seven days, with two separate Day 1 flights, so the field could fit inside the Horseshoe. It was also the first year the series was owned by Harrah’s, which had bought the Horseshoe from the remnants of the Binion family for the rights to the tournament. The top two prizes, $5,000,000 and $3,500,000, were the largest any two players had received in a poker tournament.
Online poker was the engine. Card Player and PokerNews both report that PokerStars alone supplied 315 entries, and Card Player notes that many players had won their way in through online and live satellites, the same kind of route Moneymaker had used.
Raymer was one of them. According to PokerNews, he was born in Minot, North Dakota, studied chemistry at the University of Missouri-Rolla and earned a master’s degree in biochemistry in 1989, then worked as a patent attorney for more than a decade before his win. The Associated Press reported that he was 39, lived in Stonington, Connecticut, and won his seat in a $150 PokerStars satellite.
How Greg Raymer Won the 2004 Main Event
Card Player describes Raymer as consistently aggressive from the early days, steadily building his stack into the chip lead. He reached the final table with about 8 million chips, which PokerNews calls almost a third of the chips in play. He was joined by David Williams, Josh Arieh, Dan Harrington, Glenn Hughes, Al Krux, Matt Dean, Mattias Andersson and Mike McClain.
The Final Table
Raymer used his stack immediately. Card Player reports that he eliminated four of the first five players to bust: McClain in ninth, Andersson in eighth, Krux in sixth and Hughes in fifth. Williams knocked out Dean in seventh and Harrington in fourth. Harrington’s finish meant he had reached the final table in back-to-back years, after taking third in 2003, a run Card Player called one of the greatest achievements of the modern poker era.
Arieh went next. With the shortest stack, he moved all in with pocket nines and Raymer called with ace-queen. The flop came Q-Q-J, giving Raymer three queens, and Arieh was eliminated in third for $2,500,000. That left Raymer with about 17 million chips against Williams’s 8 million or so. The AP put the stacks at $17.1 million and $8.2 million. With both men having qualified on PokerStars, an online qualifier was guaranteed to win for a second straight year.
The Final Hand
The heads-up match lasted only seven hands. Card Player’s account gives the betting: Williams opened for 300,000 and Raymer called. On a flop of 5-4-2, Raymer checked, Williams bet 500,000, Raymer raised to 1.1 million and Williams called. The turn was a 2. Raymer bet 2.5 million and Williams called.
The river was another 2. Card Player says Raymer moved all in and Williams called; the AP report describes Williams as the player who pushed all in, so accounts differ on who made the final bet. Both reports agree on the cards. Williams held ace-four for a full house, twos full of fours. Raymer turned over pocket eights for a bigger full house, twos full of eights, and the title was his.
Raymer received $5,000,000 and Williams, a 23-year-old Dallas college student according to the AP, received $3,500,000.
| Place | Player | Prize |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Greg Raymer | $5,000,000 |
| 2 | David Williams | $3,500,000 |
| 3 | Josh Arieh | $2,500,000 |
| 4 | Dan Harrington | $1,500,000 |
| 5 | Glenn Hughes | $1,100,000 |
| 6 | Al Krux | $800,000 |
| 7 | Matt Dean | $675,000 |
| 8 | Mattias Andersson | $575,000 |
| 9 | Mike McClain | $470,400 |
The prize figures above come from WSOP.com’s official results for the event. Card Player’s recap spells the sixth-place finisher’s surname two different ways; WSOP.com lists him as Al Krux.
Why Raymer’s Win Mattered
Moneymaker’s 2003 victory could have been dismissed as a fluke. Raymer’s made it a pattern. The AP opened its report by noting that, for the second consecutive year, an internet qualifier had won the famed event, and that his victory would have been astonishing had Moneymaker not done it first.
The win also showed the scale of what was happening. The Main Event had grown from 839 to 2,576 entries in a year, and it would reach 5,619 entrants in 2005, according to Card Player. PokerStars’ 315 qualifiers in 2004 were a sign of how central online poker had become to the live game.
Finally, Raymer backed up the title. Card Player’s account of 2004 portrays a champion who won through sustained aggression rather than one lucky run, and his result the following year supported that picture. As defending champion in 2005, he finished 25th out of 5,619, Card Player reports.
The Other Side of a $5 Million Story
A record first prize is only part of the picture. WSOP.com’s results show that 226 of the 2,576 entries finished in the money, which means more than nine in ten players won nothing. The $10,000 buy-in, or the satellite fees and travel costs of those who qualified, were simply lost for the great majority of the field.
The online pipeline that produced both finalists also faced a reckoning in the United States. On April 15, 2011, a date poker players call Black Friday, the U.S. Department of Justice issued an indictment against the founders of PokerStars, Full Tilt Poker and Absolute Poker, according to PokerNews, charging bank fraud, money laundering and illegal gambling. The sites that had sent so many qualifiers to Las Vegas during the boom were suddenly at the center of a federal case.
Common Myths About Fossilman’s Win
Myth: He was nicknamed Fossilman because of his age. The name comes from his habit of using fossils as card protectors. Raymer told PokerNews in 2020: “I started using a fossil as a card protector a long time ago and got the nickname ‘FossilMan.’”
Myth: He won his seat for $40, like Moneymaker. The AP reported that Moneymaker qualified through a $40 internet tournament and Raymer through a $150 PokerStars satellite.
Myth: The final hand was a bad beat. Raymer’s pocket eights led Williams’s ace-four on the flop, turn and river according to the cards reported by Card Player.
Myth: Raymer was a one-hit wonder. His 25th-place finish the next year, from a field more than twice as large, says otherwise.
More Main Event Stories to Read Next
Raymer’s win is the second chapter of a story that began with how Chris Moneymaker’s 2003 win started the poker boom, and the hand that made Moneymaker famous is retold in the Moneymaker bluff. If you want to see how Raymer and Williams got into the field, read how WSOP satellites work. The next two Main Events are covered in Joe Hachem’s 2005 final hand and Jamie Gold’s $12 million run in 2006.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources & References
- Card Player — WSOP: History — 2004 Recap
- WSOP.com — 2004 WSOP Main Event Results
- PokerNews — Greg Raymer Player Profile
- USA Today (Associated Press) — Connecticut man wins Poker World Series, $5 million
- Los Angeles Times (Associated Press) — Internet Amateur Wins Top Poker Pot
- Card Player — WSOP: History — 2005 Recap
- PokerNews — Chris Ferguson Player Profile (Black Friday background)




